
Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers and Culver’s both built loyal followings across the Midwest by pairing griddled beef with freshly churned frozen custard. Because both chains operate fast-casual dining rooms and drive-thrus with classic mid-century themes, diners frequently compare them.
Their kitchens follow different cooking methods and food philosophies. From patty searing techniques to potato cuts and batter styles, each brand targets distinct tastes. Here is how their core menus compare based on verified corporate nutrition and observed drive-thru pricing.
1. The Burgers: Thin Crisp Smash vs. Thick ButterBurger
Grill technique and patty thickness create the primary difference between the two chains.
Freddy’s Double Steakburger with Cheese
Freddy’s cooks thin patties of lean ground beef on a flat-top grill under firm, direct pressure. Pressing the meat against hot steel creates thin, jagged, caramelized borders that overhang the edge of the bun.
- Texture: Crisp and brittle at the perimeter, with a savory center seasoned with Freddy’s seasoning salt (a blend of salt, paprika, garlic, and onion).
- Build: Two thin patties, two slices of American cheese, yellow mustard, raw diced onion, and dill pickle slices on a butter-toasted commercial bun.
- Official Nutrition: 670 calories, 38g fat, 48g protein, 32g carbs, 1,560mg sodium. (Note: Online menu boards display 670 calories for the standard build, while older PDF nutrition archives listed 730 calories for builds with heavy butter spreads).
Culver’s Double ButterBurger with Cheese
Culver’s uses fresh beef seared on a flat-top grill to retain juices rather than smashed flat for lace edges.
- Texture: Thicker and juicier than Freddy’s, with a softer, beef-forward bite and lightly browned surface rather than a shatteringly crisp edge.
- Build: Two seared beef patties, Wisconsin cheddar-blend cheese, lightly buttered and toasted bun crown, with standard toppings (red onion, pickles, tomato, and mayo available upon request).
- Official Nutrition: 700 calories, 42g fat, 40g protein, 41g carbs, 950mg sodium.
- Choose Freddy’s if you prioritize texture: crispy, crunchy edges with pronounced spice seasoning.
- Choose Culver’s if you want a thicker, juicier burger with a distinct butter-toasted bun and milder beef seasoning.
2. Sides: Shoestring Fries vs. Crinkle-Cut Fries
The two chains take opposite approaches to frying potatoes.
Freddy’s Shoestring Fries
Freddy’s serves ultra-skinny shoestring potatoes fried crisp and tossed in their signature seasoning salt.
- Strengths: High crispiness when hot, excellent surface area for dipping into Freddy’s Famous Fry Sauce (a mayo-ketchup blend).
- Limitations: Thin potatoes lose thermal heat quickly. In a takeout bag, they soften noticeably within 10 minutes.
- Nutrition (Regular): 400 calories, 260mg sodium.
Culver’s Crinkle-Cut Fries
Culver’s serves traditional ridged, medium-cut crinkle fries lightly salted.
- Strengths: Fluffy potato interior that retains heat well during drive-thru transit. They pair well with Culver’s warm Wisconsin cheddar sauce.
- Limitations: Lower exterior crunch compared to shoestring cuts.
- Nutrition (Medium): 360 calories, 440mg sodium.
3. Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Both chains source cheese curds from Wisconsin, but their exterior coatings differ fundamentally.
- Freddy’s ($5.49 Regular / $8.99 Large): Uses a light, smooth batter reminiscent of tempura. The coating fries into a thin, golden shell that cracks open easily to reveal mild white cheddar (520 calories, 1,110mg sodium).
- Culver’s ($4.49 Regular / $7.49 Large): Uses a traditional, slightly thicker breadcrumb and seasoned cornmeal breading. The cheese flavor leans richer and sharper, while the coating provides a firmer crunch (510 calories, 1,460mg sodium).
4. Frozen Custard
Under US federal standards (21 CFR § 135.110), frozen custard must contain at least 10% milkfat and 1.4% egg yolk solids by weight. This formulation gives custard a thicker texture and slower melt rate than traditional soft-serve ice cream.
- Freddy’s: Focuses on freshly churned chocolate and vanilla custard. Their signature treats are Concretes, where custard is blended with mix-ins like toasted pecans, fudge, peanut butter, or strawberries. Because the custard churns continuously on-site throughout the day, it retains a dense, ribbon-like structure even after blending.
- Culver’s: Churns vanilla, chocolate, and a rotating Fresh Frozen Flavor of the Day (such as Caramel Cashew or Mint Explosion). Culver’s excels at variety, publishing a monthly flavor calendar so customers can plan visits around specific combinations.
5. Pricing and Value Comparison
Prices vary by location and franchisee. These figures reflect verified drive-thru menus recorded in Wichita, Kansas (Freddy’s home market) and Madison, Wisconsin (Culver’s home market) in October 2026:
| Item | Freddy’s (Wichita, KS) | Culver’s (Madison, WI) |
|---|---|---|
| Double Cheeseburger Solo | $7.19 – $7.79 | $6.99 – $7.49 |
| Double Cheeseburger Combo | $10.49 – $11.29 (includes fry + drink) | $10.79 – $11.69 (includes fry + drink) |
| Regular Cheese Curds | $5.49 (520 cal) | $4.49 (510 cal) |
| Medium Custard Concrete / Mixer | $5.49 – $6.19 | $4.99 – $5.79 |
Decision Guide: Which Should You Choose?
Visit Freddy’s if:
- You want a true lacy smashburger with crispy, crunchy caramelized edges.
- You love skinny seasoned shoestring fries with fry sauce pumps in the dining room.
- You prefer ultra-dense custard concretes packed with nuts and candy mix-ins.
Visit Culver’s if:
- You prefer a thicker, buttery burger that retains extra juices.
- You want crinkle fries that stay warm during takeout or delivery transit.
- You enjoy a rotating daily custard flavor menu or Midwestern dinner sides like fried butterfly shrimp.