
Key Takeaways: Frozen Custard Ordering
Freddy’s churns vanilla and chocolate frozen custard fresh multiple times daily using milk, cream, sugar, and pasteurized egg yolks across 21 menu options.
Portion size drives calorie totals sharply: a Mini Signature Turtle runs 730 to 750 calories, while a Large jumps to 1,770 to 1,820 calories.
For calorie or budget control, Custard Cookie Sandwiches deliver real frozen custard for $1.99 to $2.99 and 300 to 310 calories.
Freddy’s Frozen Custard menu features freshly churned vanilla, chocolate, and half-and-half swirl custard served as Concretes, Sundaes, Shakes, Malts, Cream Frosts, Floats, Cones, Dishes, Custard Cookie Sandwiches, and take-home Pints and Quarts. Prices run from $1.99 for an OREO Custard Sandwich to $9.99 for a 4-pack, with calories spanning 300 to 1,870+ depending on size and mix-ins.
Most online menu pages only dump a flat list of flavors and toppings. That leaves out the decisions that actually matter at the counter: how Mini, Regular, and Large portions scale in sugar and calories, which format fits your craving, and where shared-equipment allergens show up.
This guide breaks down all 21 items in the Freddy’s Frozen Custard lineup using verified nutrition figures, portion comparisons, seasonal releases, and cross-contact rules.
What Makes Freddy’s Frozen Custard Different From Ice Cream?
Frozen custard is legally defined by its egg yolk content and slow churning process. Unlike standard fast-food soft serve or packaged ice cream, Freddy’s mixes real milk, fresh cream, sugar, and pasteurized egg yolks in small batches throughout the day.
Because the machine incorporates far less air (known as overrun) than traditional ice cream, every spoonful feels denser, colder, and thicker. That density is also why a plain single vanilla custard dish carries 350 calories, 17 grams of fat, 37 grams of carbs, 30 grams of sugar, and 7 grams of protein.
Complete Freddy’s Frozen Custard Menu, Prices & Calories
Base prices vary slightly by franchise location, and third-party delivery apps typically add a markup. The table below lists all 21 frozen custard items with current baseline prices, calorie ranges from smallest to largest size, and primary allergens.
| Menu Item | Format | Base Price | Calorie Range | Primary Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OREO Custard Sandwich | Novelty | $1.99 | 310 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Chocolate Chip Custard Sandwich | Novelty | $2.99 | 300 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Dish (No Toppings) | Cup | $3.39 | 330 – 1,010 cal | Milk, Egg |
| Cone (No Toppings) | Cake / Waffle Cone | $3.39 | 360 – 1,020 cal | Milk, Wheat, Egg |
| Lemon Cream Frost | Frost | $5.49 | 450 – 1,210 cal | Milk, Egg |
| Orange Cream Frost | Frost | $5.49 | 540 – 1,500 cal | Milk, Egg |
| MUG Root Beer Float | Float | $5.69 | 420 – 850 cal | Milk, Egg |
| Shakes (Vanilla / Chocolate) | Shake | $5.99 | 560 – 1,280 cal | Milk, Egg |
| Pumpkin Pie Concrete (Seasonal) | Concrete | $6.00 | 730 – 1,770 cal | Milk, Egg, Wheat |
| Chocolate Brownie Delight | Concrete / Sundae | $6.39 | 700 – 1,710 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Strawberry Dreamcake | Concrete / Sundae | $6.39 | 860 – 1,850 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Dirt ’n Worms | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 530 – 1,360 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Peanut Butter Bananza (PBC&B) | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 560 – 1,420 cal | Milk, Soy, Egg, Peanuts |
| Maple Pecan Concrete | Concrete | $6.69 | 680 – 1,440 cal | Milk, Egg, Tree Nuts |
| OREO Double Trouble | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 700 – 1,520 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Reese’s Royale | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 860 – 1,870 cal | Milk, Soy, Egg, Peanuts |
| Signature Turtle | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 730 – 1,770 cal | Milk, Soy, Egg, Peanuts, Tree Nuts |
| Cold Brew Caramel Crunch | Concrete / Sundae | $6.69 | 790 – 1,810 cal | Milk, Soy, Egg, Tree Nuts |
| OREO Cookie Peppermint Shake (Seasonal) | Shake | $6.89 | 760 – 1,630 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
| Pints & Quarts | Take-Home Carton | $7.79 | 1,150 – 2,300 cal | Milk, Egg |
| Chocolate Chip Custard Sandwich (4-Pack) | Take-Home Box | $9.99 | 1,200 cal | Milk, Wheat, Soy, Egg |
Concretes vs. Sundaes vs. Frosts vs. Shakes: Which Format Should You Order?
Every signature creation at Freddy’s starts from the same vanilla or chocolate custard base, yet the preparation style changes texture, sweetness, and how quickly you finish it.
- Concretes: Thick custard blended all the way through with candy, cookies, fruit, or hot fudge on a spindle mixer. Choose a Concrete when you want every spoonful packed with mix-ins.
- Sundaes: Custard layered with syrup and toppings, finished with whipped cream and a cherry. Because toppings sit on top rather than blended throughout, Sundaes taste slightly lighter than Concretes of the same flavor.
- Cream Frosts: Vanilla custard blended with citrus slush or soda (such as the Lemon Cream Frost or Orange Cream Frost). These drink like a creamy creamsicle and work well after a salty steakburger.
- Shakes and Malts: Custard thinned with milk until sip-ready. Adding malt powder bumps a standard shake by roughly 40 to 70 calories depending on size and introduces wheat/gluten.
- Floats: The MUG Root Beer Float pairs vanilla custard with cold root beer for 420 to 850 calories, making it easier on sugar than heavy fudge concretes.
Size & Calorie Reality: Mini vs. Regular vs. Large
Portion sizing is the fastest way to overeat at Freddy’s. A Mini Concrete already delivers a full dessert portion, while stepping up to a Large can double or more than double total sugar and calories.
Look at how verified nutrition figures scale on the Signature Turtle (vanilla custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, toasted pecans, whipped cream, and a cherry):
| Signature Turtle Size | Calories | Total Fat | Carbs | Sugar | Protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mini | 730 – 750 cal | 36g | 91g | 72g | 10g |
| Regular | 1,070 – 1,090 cal | 51 – 53g | 124g | 102g | 18g |
| Large | 1,770 – 1,820 cal | 83 – 84g | 211 – 229g | 170 – 175g | 24 – 28g |
The same pattern holds across other loaded concretes. A Mini Chocolate Brownie Delight Concrete runs 700 calories (31g fat, 73g sugar, 10g protein), while a Regular jumps to 1,040 calories (47g fat, 103g sugar, 19g protein). Even a Mini Dirt ’n Worms Sundae (570 calories, 56g sugar) or Mini PBC&B Sundae (570 calories, 51g sugar) is plenty for one person.
If you want real Freddy’s custard without a 700+ calorie commitment, order the OREO Custard Sandwich ($1.99, 310 cal) or Chocolate Chip Custard Sandwich ($2.99, 300 cal). Both are pre-portioned, easy to eat in the car, and lower in calories than any Mini Concrete.
Best Signature Concretes & 2026 Seasonal Flavors
Freddy’s keeps nine core specialty flavors on the menu year-round and rotates limited-time treats each season:
Year-Round Crowd Favorites
- Signature Turtle ($6.69): Vanilla custard, hot fudge, hot caramel, and roasted pecans. Rich, salty-sweet, and the benchmark order for first-time guests.
- OREO Double Trouble ($6.69): Vanilla custard blended with a double portion of chopped OREO cookies and topped with whipped cream.
- Reese’s Royale ($6.69): Vanilla custard mixed with Reese’s peanut butter sauce and chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (860 to 1,870 cal).
- Cold Brew Caramel Crunch ($6.69): Vanilla custard blended with cold brew coffee, chopped Heath toffee, and caramel sauce for a bitter-sweet finish.
- Strawberry Dreamcake ($6.39): Vanilla custard with strawberry puree, New York cheesecake pieces, and cinnamon streusel.
Seasonal Limited-Time Offerings (Fall & Winter 2026)
Freddy’s brought back the Pumpkin Pie Concrete nationwide starting November 12 while supplies last. Instead of pumpkin syrup, staff blend vanilla frozen custard with an entire slice of real pumpkin pie (crust included), then finish it with whipped cream and cinnamon. For winter peppermint fans, the OREO Cookie Peppermint Shake ($6.89, 760 to 1,630 cal) pairs crushed peppermint with OREO pieces.
Complete Toppings, Mix-Ins & Customization Options
You can start with a plain Dish or Cone ($3.39) or build a custom concrete with your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or half-and-half swirl. Extra mix-ins typically add around $0.50 to $0.79 each depending on the restaurant.
- Sauces & Syrups: Hot fudge, hot caramel, chocolate, butterscotch, peanut butter, marshmallow, strawberry, pineapple, and coffee flavoring.
- Cookies & Candy: OREO cookies, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Reese’s Pieces, M&M’s, Snickers, Butterfinger, Heath Toffee, cookie dough, chocolate chips, and brownie pieces.
- Fruit, Nuts & Extras: Banana, cherries, cheesecake pieces, toasted coconut, rainbow sprinkles, peanuts, pecans, almonds, cashews, and macadamia nuts.
Ask for a half-and-half vanilla and chocolate swirl at no extra charge, or order a plain Mini Dish ($3.39) with one fruit or nut topping instead of hot fudge and candy to keep dessert near 400 calories. Buying Pints & Quarts ($7.79) also lets families split custard at home across multiple bowls.
Allergens & Cross-Contact Disclosures
Every frozen custard base at Freddy’s contains milk and pasteurized egg yolks. There is no dairy-free, egg-free, or vegan frozen custard option. Plain vanilla or chocolate custard in a dish contains no wheat ingredients, but Freddy’s kitchens use shared scoopers, shared blending spindles, and adjacent nut and cookie topping bins where cross-contact can occur. Guests with celiac disease or severe nut allergies should notify a manager and ask for custard scooped from a fresh container with sanitized utensils.
Looking for a full meal before dessert? Pair a lighter treat like the OREO Custard Sandwich with an item from our Freddy’s Low-Calorie Menu Guide or Freddy’s High-Protein Menu Guide.